Should You Sign Over Your Insurance Check to a Roofer?

Let’s set the stage. Your roof just took a beating—maybe from a storm, hail, or some other disaster. You filed an insurance claim, and the company cut you a check to cover the damages. Then, your roofer shows up, ready to start repairs, but they ask for one thing: your insurance check.

At first glance, it might seem like a no-brainer. They handle the roof repairs; you don’t have to lift a finger. Right? Well, not so fast. Handing over that check could lead to big problems if you’re not careful.

Let’s be clear: not all roofers who ask for the check are trying to scam you. Some legit roofing companies offer this as a convenience to simplify the process. But the key word here is some. Others? Well, they could be setting you up for headaches you don’t even know are coming.

Wait—Why Do Roofers Even Ask for the Check?

To understand the “why,” let’s break it down:

It Streamlines Their Process:
By getting the insurance check directly, the roofer doesn’t have to wait for you to cash it, pay them, and manage paperwork.
Guarantees Payment for the Work:
Some roofers ask for the check upfront to ensure they’ll be paid. This allows them to avoid chasing down homeowners who might delay payments.
Helps Cover Material Costs:
Roofing materials are expensive. The roofer might need the funds to purchase supplies before starting the job.

These reasons might sound legit, and sometimes they are. But here’s where you need to tread carefully—once that check leaves your hands, control of the situation is no longer yours.

Red Flags to Watch Out For

Handing over your insurance check without doing your homework is like walking into a dark alley without a flashlight. Here’s what to watch for:

They’re Rushing You to Sign It Over:
If a roofer is pushy or tries to pressure you into handing over the check, hit the brakes. A trustworthy contractor will respect your time and explain the process in detail.
They Want You to Sign Before Work Starts:
Don’t sign the check unless you have a detailed, written contract in hand. This contract should outline the scope of work, costs, and timelines.
They Offer to Waive Your Deductible:
It might sound like a sweet deal, but beware. Waiving deductibles is often illegal, and companies that make these offers might not have your best interests at heart.
The Estimate Doesn’t Add Up:
Compare the roofer’s estimate with your insurance company’s payout. If the numbers are wildly different, that’s a red flag. You should always ask for clarification before moving forward.

How to Protect Yourself (and Still Get the Job Done)

Look, not every roofer asking for the check is out to scam you. But you need to take steps to ensure you’re working with a reliable contractor. Here’s how:

Vet the Company Thoroughly:
Check their reviews online, ask for references, and ensure they’re licensed and insured. If anything feels off, walk away.
Demand a Detailed Contract:
Everything should be spelled out in writing. This includes the timeline, materials, costs, and payment terms.
Consider Escrow Services:
Instead of handing over the check, look into escrow services. These hold the funds until the work is complete and inspected, protecting you and the roofer.
Talk to Your Insurance Adjuster:
Before signing the check, include your insurance adjuster. They can confirm the roofer’s estimate and provide guidance.
Never Skip the Walkthrough:
Once the work is done, do a walkthrough with the roofer before releasing any payment. You want to make sure everything is up to par before they disappear.

What’s the Worst That Could Happen?

Here’s why you need to stay vigilant:

Shoddy Work: Some roofers take the check, slap together a quick repair, and vanish—leaving you with more problems.
Overcharging: Unscrupulous contractors might inflate costs, leaving you footing the bill for unnecessary repairs.
Legal Trouble: If the roofer doesn’t pay their suppliers, you could have a lien on your property.

Honest Roofers Exist, and JM Exteriors Roofing Siding is Proof of That—You Just Have to Be Careful

Reputable roofers can help you navigate insurance claims and get your roof back in shape. Many genuinely want to make the process as painless as possible for you.

But when signing over your insurance check, caution is your best friend. Do your research, ask questions, and don’t hesitate to say no if something doesn’t feel right. Your roof is a significant investment—and so is your peace of mind.

Reach out to JM Exteriors Roofing Siding for any roofing service you need; we can also help you navigate your insurance claim process.

Table of Contents

Add a header to begin generating the table of contents