Fiber Cement Siding Pros and Cons for a New England House
The main fiber cement siding pros and cons are simple: it is durable, resists fire, rot and insects, and holds paint well, but it is heavy, costs more to install than vinyl and needs repainting over time. For a New England house that faces wet springs, humid summers and freeze-thaw winters, it is a strong choice when it is installed and sealed correctly.
This guide covers what fiber cement is, its advantages and drawbacks, how it handles our climate, how it compares with vinyl and metal and who it suits best.
What is fiber cement siding?
Fiber cement siding is made of cement, sand and cellulose fibers pressed into boards and panels. It comes in lap boards, shingles, panels and vertical styles, often with a wood-grain or smooth face.
- Usually sold primed or with a factory-applied finish
- Available in lap, shingle, panel and board and batten styles
- Cut with special tools and dust control on site
- Installed over a weather-resistant barrier, like other siding
JM Exteriors Roofing Siding names fiber cement among the siding it installs, together with board and batten and metal siding. For the vertical style, see the company's guide on what board and batten siding is.
What are the advantages of fiber cement siding?
Its main advantages are durability and stability. It does not behave like wood or plastic in the weather.
- Does not rot and is not food for insects or woodpeckers
- Is noncombustible, which adds a layer of fire resistance
- Stays flat and stable through heat and cold
- Holds paint well, so finishes tend to last longer than on wood
- Can convincingly imitate painted wood clapboard and shingles
- Resists dents from hail and impacts better than thin siding
For older New England homes with a traditional look, fiber cement can keep the character of painted clapboard while avoiding much of the upkeep of real wood.
What are the drawbacks of fiber cement siding?
The drawbacks are weight, cost and attention to detail during installation. None of them rule it out, but they are worth knowing.
- Heavier than vinyl, so it takes more labor to handle and hang
- Usually costs more installed than vinyl siding
- Cutting creates fine dust that needs proper tools and protection
- Joints, ends and cut edges must be sealed and flashed carefully
- Needs repainting eventually, although less often than wood
- Must keep the right clearance from the roof, decks and ground
Most problems with fiber cement come from installation shortcuts, such as boards set too close to the ground or unflashed joints, not from the material itself.
Is fiber cement siding good in cold climates?
Yes, when it is installed to the manufacturer's instructions. Fiber cement siding in cold climates performs well because it does not expand and contract as much as vinyl, and it does not become brittle in the cold.
- Proper clearance above roofs and grade keeps snow and splash away from the bottom edges
- Sealed and primed cut edges stop water from soaking in and freezing
- A weather-resistant barrier and flashing behind the siding handle any water that gets past
- Painting in the right season helps the finish cure before winter
How does fiber cement compare with vinyl and metal siding?
Each has its place. Fiber cement vs vinyl siding is usually a choice between a heavier, more solid wall and a lighter, lower-cost one.
- Vinyl: lighter and less costly, does not need paint, can crack in hard cold impacts and can look less like real wood up close
- Fiber cement: heavier and more costly to install, very stable, looks like painted wood, needs repainting over time
- Metal: very durable and low maintenance, often chosen for modern designs, can dent depending on the product
If a wood look is the goal on a smaller budget, the company's post on wood-look vinyl siding describes that option.
Is fiber cement siding worth it?
It is worth it for homeowners who plan to stay in the house for years and want a durable, painted-wood look. It is less of a fit when the budget is tight or the main goal is no painting at all.
- Good fit: long-term owners, traditional styles, houses near trees or in exposed spots
- Good fit: owners who want fire and pest resistance
- Less of a fit: tight budgets where vinyl meets the need
- Less of a fit: owners who never want to repaint
Ask any installer which product line they recommend, what the manufacturer's warranty covers and how they will handle flashing and clearances on your house.
Frequently asked questions about fiber cement siding
How long does fiber cement siding last?
Fiber cement siding typically lasts many decades when it is installed and maintained properly. The finish usually needs attention before the boards do. The manufacturer's warranty for the product you choose is the best guide to what to expect.
Does fiber cement siding need to be painted?
Yes, over time. Boards come primed or prefinished, and a factory finish usually lasts longer than one applied by hand. Plan for repainting eventually, typically less often than painted wood.
Can fiber cement siding be installed in winter?
It can be installed in cold weather, but caulking and painting have temperature limits on their labels. Many homeowners schedule siding work from spring to fall so sealing and painting can be done in good conditions.
Is fiber cement siding hard to repair?
Damaged boards can usually be replaced individually. The new board is cut, installed, sealed and painted to match. Matching an older painted wall may mean repainting a larger area so the color looks even.
Plan your siding project with JM Exteriors Roofing Siding
JM Exteriors Roofing Siding is a roofing and siding contractor based in Lowell, MA, that installs fiber cement, board and batten and metal siding, along with roofing, gutters and chimney repair. It serves Lowell, Westford, Andover, Tewksbury and Chelmsford in Massachusetts, and Nashua, Londonderry, Derry and Manchester in New Hampshire. See its siding and roofing services, call 603-966-8281 or contact JM Exteriors Roofing Siding for a free estimate.
